When something hurts, the instinct is to stop everything until it feels better. For a fresh, significant injury that can be the right call for a short time. For the far more common case—a cranky knee, a sore shoulder, a back that complains after deadlifts—complete rest is rarely the quickest way back.
Rest deconditions everything that was not injured. By the time the painful area settles, you have lost strength and work capacity everywhere else, and the return feels twice as hard. Tissues also adapt to the loads they see; a tendon or joint that sees no load gets less able to tolerate load, not more.
Pain is a signal, not a damage meter
Pain science has moved a long way from the idea that pain equals damage. Pain is the nervous system's protective output, and it is shaped by tissue state, sleep, stress, recent load and what you expect to happen. That is why the same lift can hurt on a bad week and feel fine on a good one.
This does not mean pain is imaginary or should be ignored. It means a moderate, stable amount of discomfort during training is usually not a sign you are causing harm, and that sensitivity can be trained down by exposure that is gradual and predictable.
Find the version you tolerate
The usable principle is to change the movement until it becomes tolerable, then load that. A painful back squat might become a box squat to a higher box, a split squat, a leg press, or a goblet squat with a 25 lb dumbbell. A painful overhead press might become a landmine press or an incline press with a neutral grip.
The levers are range of motion, load, speed, stance or grip, and the implement. Change one at a time. Meanwhile, keep training everything unaffected as normal—a sore shoulder is no reason to stop squatting.
A simple rule for what counts as tolerable
A widely used approach is to rate pain from 0 to 10. During the session, staying at or below about 3 out of 10 is generally acceptable. Afterwards, symptoms should settle back to your usual baseline within about 24 hours. Across weeks, things should be stable or improving.
If pain climbs during the set, lingers past the next day, or trends worse week to week, that is the cue to reduce load or range, not to push through. Individual tolerance varies a great deal, so treat the numbers as a starting guide rather than a rule.
What to do this week
Pick the movement that hurts and find one variation that stays at or below 3 out of 10. Do it twice this week at a load that feels moderate, and note how it feels the next morning. If it settles, add a little load or range next week. If it does not, step back one notch and repeat.
Part of